The recruiting landscape has changed dramatically. While you're obsessing over goals, assists, and times, college coaches are evaluating something entirely different.
Every year, thousands of talented athletes send emails to college coaches with their highlight reels and stat sheets—only to receive generic responses or complete silence. Here's the uncomfortable truth: your stats don't matter as much as you think.
In 2026, with the NCAA Transfer Portal creating unprecedented roster instability, college coaches have shifted their priorities. They're not looking for the player with the most goals or fastest 40-yard dash. They're looking for something entirely different—and far more important for their program's success.
Coaches are looking for recruits who can contribute immediately, handle adversity, and—most importantly—make their teammates better. The transfer portal has made this more critical than ever because roster spots are precious and unpredictable.
This is #1 for a reason. In our conversations with over 50 Division I coaches this year, every single one mentioned coachability as their top priority. Here's what they mean:
Coach's Quote: "I'd rather recruit a slightly less talented player who's coachable than a superstar who thinks they know everything. I can improve skill; I can't change attitude." — Division I Women's Soccer Coach
Coaches can teach fundamentals, but they can't teach game sense. They're looking for athletes who:
Real Talk: A player with average speed but excellent game awareness will always outperform a fast player with low IQ. Coaches see this constantly.
College programs are micro-communities. Coaches carefully evaluate how you'll impact their team culture:
Why It Matters: One toxic player can destroy team chemistry. Coaches would rather take a slightly less talented player with great character than a problem child with all the skills.
This is non-negotiable. Here's what coaches really think about academics:
Wake Up Call: If you're struggling academically, coaches assume you'll struggle athletically too. It's about discipline and priorities.
Now we get to the athletic part—but it's not what you think:
The Truth: In highlight videos, coaches are looking for HOW you move, not just WHAT you do. They want to see athleticism and body control, not just goals.
In 2026, over 2,000+ athletes enter the transfer portal every year. This has fundamentally changed what coaches look for:
Show your game IQ, not just highlights. Include clips of you communicating, encouraging teammates, and making smart decisions.
Don't lead with stats. Lead with your character, work ethic, and coachability. Show coaches who you are as a person.
Ask coaches, teachers, or club managers to mention your character in their recommendations. This carries weight.
If your grades need work, fix them NOW. Nothing says "responsible" like strong academics.
We help international student-athletes navigate the college recruiting process with proven strategies that work. Don't waste time on what doesn't matter—focus on what coaches actually want.
Our step-by-step guide to getting recruited, updated for 2026.
Get expert feedback on your highlight video and profile.
Personalized recruiting strategy sessions with our experts.