The ultimate guide for soccer players aged 16-20 facing the biggest decision of their career
If you're a soccer player between 16-20 years old, you're standing at one of the most critical crossroads of your athletic career. The decision you make now could define your entire future—both on and off the field.
Should you pursue professional trials now and focus 100% on going pro? Or should you choose the college soccer route, earning a degree while developing your game in a structured environment?
This isn't a decision to make lightly. It requires honest self-assessment, understanding the full picture of each pathway, and aligning your choice with your long-term goals. Let's break down everything you need to know.
TNS Recruitment specializes in helping international soccer players navigate both pro trials and college pathways. Our team has placed hundreds of athletes in top programs across the USA and Europe.
Professional soccer trials are short-term tryout opportunities with professional clubs where coaches evaluate your technical skills, tactical intelligence, physical fitness, and mental toughness. These trials can take place with:
Trials typically last anywhere from a few days to several weeks. During this time, coaches assess:
First touch, passing accuracy, shooting technique, dribbling ability, ball control under pressure
Positioning, decision-making, game awareness, understanding of team tactics, adaptability
Speed, endurance, strength, agility, recovery ability, injury history
The college soccer pathway combines competitive soccer with higher education in the United States and Canada. You play for a university team while earning your degree, creating a balanced approach to athletic and academic development.
Highest level of college soccer with athletic scholarships available. D1 offers full rides, D2 offers partial scholarships.
No athletic scholarships, but academic and need-based aid available. Focus on academics with competitive soccer.
National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics - smaller schools with athletic scholarships and more flexible eligibility.
Two-year programs that serve as stepping stones to NCAA D1/D2 schools. Affordable and accessible entry point.
Canadian university soccer system. Less expensive than US options with high-quality education and competitive soccer. Popular among international players, especially from Europe.
Want to reach out to college coaches directly? We provide verified email lists for NCAA D1, D2, D3, NAIA, and JUCO programs across all sports. Start building relationships with coaches today.
Injury is the silent career killer in soccer. Whether you choose pro trials or college, understanding the physical demands and injury risks is absolutely critical to making an informed decision.
At 16-20 years old, your body is still developing. Growth plates haven't fully closed, muscles and tendons are still maturing, and your skeletal structure is not yet at peak strength. Pushing too hard, too early can lead to:
Professional trials and academy contracts push players to their absolute physical limits. You're training alongside fully developed adult athletes, often 3-5 years older than you. The intensity is relentless:
Result: Higher injury rates among young pro players, especially ages 16-19
College programs are regulated by NCAA rules that limit practice hours and mandate rest periods. Most programs have:
Result: Players develop physically in a safer, more controlled environment
If you're under 20 years old, giving your body 2-4 more years to fully develop in a college environment significantly reduces your lifetime injury risk and can actually extend your professional career by protecting your body during critical growth years.
Many professional players who went to college first report fewer career-ending injuries and longer playing careers compared to peers who went pro at 16-18.
Timing is everything in soccer. The age at which you enter the professional world or college system can dramatically impact your long-term success.
Pro soccer favors younger athletes for development contracts
College athletes peak later but enter pro game more developed
Not everyone is elite at 16. Many players physically and mentally mature between 18-22. College soccer gives you that crucial development time without sacrificing your professional dreams.
"I wasn't physically ready for pro soccer at 18. College gave me 4 years to develop my body, game IQ, and confidence. I signed a pro contract at 22 and played 8 years professionally." - Former D1 player
Getting seen by the right people is critical to advancing your soccer career, whether you're aiming for a pro contract or college scholarship.
Pros: Direct evaluation by professional scouts and coaches
Cons: Short time to impress, extremely competitive, limited second chances
Pros: 4 years to develop, multiple showcases, consistent visibility
Cons: NCAA D3 gets less pro scout attention than D1 or pro academies
Whether you're pursuing pro trials or college recruitment, a high-quality highlight video is essential. TNS Recruitment offers professional video editing services tailored specifically for soccer players.
Learn About Video ServicesUnderstanding where each path leads after your initial years is crucial. Let's look at the realistic outcomes for both routes.
Reality Check: Only 1-2% of academy players make it to top-tier professional contracts
Key Advantage: 100% of college soccer players graduate with a degree and career options
Pro Trial Path:
College Path:
This decision is personal and unique to YOUR situation. Here are the critical factors you must honestly evaluate before making your choice.
Be brutally honest with yourself:
If you're not clearly elite yet, college gives you time to develop without sacrificing education.
Consider your academic standing:
Strong students often thrive in college environments and benefit from the dual opportunity.
Money matters - be realistic:
College scholarships can cover $40-60K+/year. Pro trials with no contract = debt and no degree.
Think about your life beyond soccer:
Your mental health and personal development matter just as much as your soccer career.
Who's in your corner?
Beware of agents pushing young players into pro trials prematurely for commission.
Still unsure which path is right for you? Our experienced recruitment consultants have helped hundreds of soccer players make this exact decision. We provide personalized assessments, honest feedback, and guidance based on YOUR specific situation—not a one-size-fits-all approach.
Learn from players who've walked both paths. These are real stories (names changed for privacy) that illustrate the outcomes of each route.
Age 18 → Professional Contract
The Path: Marco was playing for a top youth academy in Spain at 16. By 18, he earned a first-team contract with a La Liga 2 club. He's now 24 and playing professionally in Europe.
Key Factors: Elite skill level from a young age, already in professional academy system, family support, mentally mature, clear standout among peers.
"I knew from 15 that I was good enough for the pro level. My coaches told me I was ready. Going pro was the right decision for me because I was already training with first team players." - Marco
Age 17 → Released at 20 → No Degree
The Path: James signed with an MLS academy at 17, left high school early. Released at 20 with no pro contract. Now 23, working retail, and deeply regrets not pursuing college soccer.
Key Factors: Good but not elite, injuries during development years, no backup plan, limited education, struggled to find opportunities after release.
"I wish someone had been honest with me about my chances. I gave up education for a 2% shot. If I could do it over, I'd choose college 100%." - James
Age 18-22 NCAA D1 → Pro Contract at 22
The Path: Sofia played NCAA D1 soccer for 4 years, graduated with a business degree, and signed with the NWSL at 22. She's now 26, still playing pro, and has her degree as a safety net.
Key Factors: Strong academics, developed physically 18-22, elite training in college, scouts attended games, graduated debt-free on scholarship.
"College gave me time to grow up, develop my body, and get an education. I wasn't ready for pro soccer at 18. By 22, I was. Best decision I ever made." - Sofia
Age 18-22 NCAA D2 → Sports Marketing Career
The Path: Ahmed played D2 soccer, graduated with a marketing degree, and now works for a major sports brand. He coaches youth soccer on weekends and has zero regrets about not going pro.
Key Factors: Recognized he wasn't elite level, valued education, built connections through college, stayed involved in soccer through coaching and career.
"I loved playing college soccer and got a degree that landed me my dream job. Not everyone has to go pro to have a successful soccer career." - Ahmed
Ready to make your decision? Use this actionable checklist to guide you through the process.
Some players successfully try pro trials first (ages 18-19), and if it doesn't work out, they enroll in college at 19-20. This is risky but possible if you:
Warning: The longer you wait, the harder it is to qualify for college and scholarships!
There's no universal "right answer" to the pro trials vs. college debate. The best path depends entirely on your unique situation, skills, goals, and circumstances.
"The average professional soccer career lasts 8 years. The average working career lasts 40+ years. Choose the path that sets you up for BOTH success on the field AND success in life."
— TNS Recruitment Team
Whatever path you choose, commit to it fully. If you choose pro trials, give it everything. If you choose college, maximize the opportunity—excel academically, develop your game, and build your network.
Remember: Success isn't just about where you start—it's about how hard you work, how you handle adversity, and whether you made the choice that aligned with YOUR values and goals. Both paths can lead to incredible outcomes if you approach them with dedication, humility, and strategic thinking.
Don't navigate this critical decision alone. TNS Recruitment provides expert guidance, verified coach contact lists, professional video services, and comprehensive recruitment support to help you succeed—whether you choose pro trials or college soccer.
Access verified emails for NCAA, NAIA, and JUCO coaches across all sports
Browse Lists →